Difference Between Open Heart Surgery and Bypass Surgery

By Author : Dr. Deepanshu Siwach
  calender 20 January,2025
Difference Between Open Heart Surgery and Bypass Surgery

When it comes to heart surgery, many of us might picture something straight out of a medical drama – a frantic race against time, a skilled surgeon wielding a scalpel, and a life hanging in the balance. But in reality, heart bypass surgery (CABG) and open-heart surgery are far more common than we think. Every year, over 600,000 heart bypass surgeries are performed worldwide, making it one of the most frequently conducted surgical procedures. While these surgeries might sound intimidating, the survival rates paint a different picture. With 90% of bypass patients making it through the first five years, the odds are in your favor if you need one. So, what's the difference between the two? Let's dive into the fascinating world of heart surgery and discover the facts that might surprise you!

What is an Open Heart Surgery?

Open-heart surgery involves opening the chest to operate on the heart. It treats conditions like coronary artery disease, valve problems, and heart defects. The procedure involves cutting through the sternum to access the heart. During the procedure, a heart-lung bypass machine may take over the heart's function, ensuring continuous blood flow and oxygen supply to the body.

The most common type of open-heart surgery is CABG. This procedure reroutes blood around blocked arteries to improve blood flow. Surgeons also use open-heart surgery to repair valves, correct congenital disorders, and address heart aneurysms. In some cases, the heart is stopped temporarily during the operation.

Heart patients receive general anesthesia to ensure they are unconscious and pain-free. After surgery, the heart typically restarts naturally or with mild shocks if needed. The procedure requires precise techniques and advanced equipment. Open-heart surgery remains a reliable method for treating severe heart problems.

Recovery after surgery takes time and involves careful monitoring. Patients may need medications and lifestyle changes to ensure long-term success. Open-heart surgery is a significant medical advancement that has saved countless lives. It plays a vital role in treating complex heart conditions effectively.

When is Open Heart Surgery Needed?

Doctors recommend open-heart surgery to treat severe heart conditions. Surgeons perform it to address blockages causing chest pain or reduced blood flow. They use surgery when previous treatments fail or arteries re-narrow. Blocked left coronary arteries often require surgery to restore blood flow. Surgeons also operate if the left ventricle struggles to pump blood properly.

Conditions Requiring Open-Heart Surgery

Doctors perform surgery to treat blockages causing coronary artery disease. They repair or replace damaged valves disrupting blood flow. Surgeons correct congenital disabilities affecting heart structure and function. They fix aneurysms to prevent rupture or life-threatening complications. In advanced heart failure, doctors consider surgery when other treatments fail.

Common Types of Open-Heart Surgery

As discussed earlier, cardiologists decide on surgery type based on condition and patient health.

  • Coronary Artery Bypass Grafting (CABG): Surgeons create a new path for blood using healthy arteries or veins.
  • Heart Valve Repair or Replacement: Doctors repair or replace valves with artificial or biological ones.
  • Pacemaker or ICD Implantation: Surgeons implant devices to correct or regulate irregular heart rhythms.
  • Maze Surgery: Surgeons create scar tissue to block abnormal heart signals.
  • Aneurysm Repair: Doctors replace weak artery sections or heart walls with grafts.
  • Heart Transplant: Surgeons replace a diseased heart with a healthy donor heart.
  • VAD or TAH Insertion: Surgeons implant mechanical devices to support or replace heart function.

How is Open Heart Surgery Performed?

Open-heart surgery is a complex procedure that can take several hours. The surgery steps may vary depending on the specific condition being treated, but the general process includes:

  • Preparation and Anesthesia: Doctors administer general anesthesia to ensure the patient remains unconscious and pain-free. Cardiac surgeons monitor the patient closely throughout the procedure.
  • Incision and Access: Surgeons make a 6 to 10-inch incision in the middle of the chest. The breastbone is cut, and the ribcage is spread apart to expose the heart.
  • Heart-Lung Bypass (if required): In on-pump surgeries, surgeons affix the heart to a heart-lung bypass machine. Medication stops the heart, allowing surgeons to operate while the machine maintains blood flow and oxygen supply.
  • Surgical Repair: The surgeon performs the necessary repair, such as bypassing blocked arteries, replacing valves, or fixing defects.
  • Restarting the Heart: Once repairs are complete, the heart is restarted, often on its own or with mild electric shocks. The bypass machine is disconnected.
  • Closing the Incision: The breastbone is closed using wires, which remain inside the body permanently. Stitches or staples are used to close the skin incision.

Recovery Post-Surgery

Open-heart surgery patients are transferred to the intensive care unit (ICU) for close monitoring. Once stable, they are moved to a general hospital room. Recovery time in the hospital varies depending on the complexity of the surgery.

Note: Pre-surgery, patients must disclose all medications and habits (e.g., smoking) to their doctor. They may need to stop blood-thinning medicines, smoking, and alcohol use weeks before surgery.

What is a Heart Bypass Surgery?

Heart bypass surgery, or simple bypass surgery, is also called coronary artery bypass grafting. It is a surgical procedure that restores proper blood flow to the heart. Surgeons perform this surgery to bypass blocked or narrowed coronary arteries that restrict blood supply to the heart muscle.

During the procedure, the surgeon takes a healthy blood vessel from another body part, often the chest, leg, or arm. They then graft this blood vessel onto the coronary artery, connecting it above and below the blockage. It helps create a new pathway for blood to flow, bypassing the obstruction and supplying oxygen-rich blood to the heart.

Heart bypass surgery is commonly performed as open-heart surgery. However, in some cases, cardiac surgeons may use less invasive methods. It is often recommended when other treatments, such as medication or less invasive procedures, fail to provide relief or if the patient is at high risk for a heart attack.

This surgery helps relieve symptoms like chest pain, improves heart function, and lowers the risk of future heart problems. It is especially beneficial for patients who have suffered a heart attack or are at risk of severe complications due to blocked arteries.

When is Bypass Surgery Required?

Why do you need bypass surgery

Bypass surgery is necessary when coronary arteries are severely blocked or narrowed, compromising blood flow to the heart. This procedure is advised under the following conditions:

  • Coronary Artery Disease (CAD): Significant blockages in the coronary arteries reduce oxygen-rich blood supply to the heart muscle.
  • Heart Attack: Emergency bypass surgery may be performed to restore adequate blood flow and prevent further damage.
  • Angina Pectoris: Severe chest pain caused by restricted blood flow may necessitate bypass surgery.
  • Myocardial Ischaemia: A condition where inadequate blood flow causes damage to the heart tissue.
  • Failed Angioplasty: If minimally invasive procedures like angioplasty or stenting do not restore blood flow.

Doctors may recommend bypass surgery to reduce the risk of heart attacks, alleviate symptoms, and improve overall heart function. The decision depends on the severity of the condition, overall health, and previous treatments.

How is a Heart Bypass Surgery Performed?

Heart bypass surgery re-establishes blood flow to the heart by creating new pathways around blocked arteries. It can be performed as an open surgery or through minimally invasive techniques.

Open Heart Bypass Surgery:

  • The surgeon administers general anesthesia to put the patient to sleep.
  • They make a 6-8 inch incision along the chest to access the heart.
  • The breastbone is cut and spread apart to expose the heart.
  • A heart-lung bypass machine takes over the heart and lung functions.
  • The surgeon stops the heart temporarily using medication.
  • They remove a healthy blood vessel from the leg, chest, or arm to use as a graft.
  • The surgeon attaches the graft above and below the blockage to create a new blood flow route.
  • The heart is restarted, often using mild electrical shocks.
  • The breastbone is closed with metal wires, and the skin incision is stitched.
  • It typically takes 2 to 6 hours.

Minimally Invasive Heart Bypass Surgery:

  • The surgeon uses general anesthesia to keep the patient asleep.
  • Instead of a large incision, they make small cuts (3-5 inches) in the chest.
  • Specialized tools and a small camera with light are inserted through the cuts.
  • The surgeon harvests a healthy vessel from the body for grafting.
  • They perform the grafting procedure using the camera to guide them.
  • The heart continues beating during the surgery, so no heart-lung machine is needed.
  • After grafting, the surgeon removes the tools and closes the small incisions.
  • Minimally invasive CABG takes 2 to 4 hours to complete.

After the procedure, the patient is moved to the intensive care unit (ICU) for close monitoring. Recovery involves several days in the hospital and careful follow-up care. Minimally invasive surgery often results in faster recovery and less pain. However, open surgery is still necessary for more complex cases. The surgeon chooses the method based on the patient's condition.

What is the Difference Between Open Heart Surgery and Bypass Surgery?

Open heart surgery and bypass surgery are both performed to treat heart conditions, but they differ in scope, purpose, and technique.

  • Open heart surgery is a broad term for surgeries where the chest is opened to access the heart or its surrounding structures. This surgery may involve the heart muscles, valves, arteries, or other parts. It treats heart conditions like valve repairs, congenital defects, aneurysms, and heart transplants.
  • Bypass surgery, on the other hand, is a specific type of open heart surgery focusing on improving blood flow to the heart. It primarily addresses coronary artery disease by bypassing blocked coronary arteries with grafts from other body parts. Bypass surgery aims to reduce the risk of heart attacks, relieve chest pain (angina), and improve overall heart function.
  • In terms of technique, open heart surgery requires a large incision in the chest, and it often involves the use of a heart-lung machine to circulate blood while the heart is stopped. Open heart surgeries may address multiple issues in the heart, including structural repairs or replacements. Bypass surgery, however, involves grafting healthy blood vessels to bypass blocked arteries. Surgeons can perform it with or without the use of a heart-lung machine, depending on the type of bypass surgery performed.
  • While open heart surgery treats a variety of conditions, including valve disease, heart failure, and aneurysms, bypass surgery specifically targets coronary artery disease. It focuses on restoring blood flow to the heart. Recovery from open heart surgery depends on the complexity of the procedure, while bypass surgery recovery focuses more on healing the grafts and managing coronary artery disease.

What is the Survival Rate of Bypass v/s Open Heart Surgery?

Survival rate of open heart vs. bypass surgery

The survival rates for both bypass surgery and open-heart surgery are generally high, with many factors influencing the long-term outcomes. These factors include the patient's overall health, age, the severity of heart disease, and how well the patient follows post-surgery care instructions.

  • Studies have shown that the survival rate for bypass surgery is approximately 90% five years after the surgery. However, over time, the survival rate can decrease. Research indicates that the ten-year survival rate for bypass surgery is about 74%. After 20 years, the survival rate drops to around 39%; after 30 years, it is approximately 14%.
  • A 2021 study reported that the operative mortality rate for coronary artery bypass surgery is 2.2%, meaning 2.2% of patients die within 30 days of the procedure. Moreover, after one year, the mortality rate for bypass surgery is approximately 6%. However, many patients continue to experience long-term benefits and improved quality of life after the procedure.
  • The survival rate for open-heart surgery typically depends on the particular procedure and the patient's health. For example, a study indicates that the survival rate for patients undergoing open-heart surgery can be as high as 82-94%, depending on the complexity of the surgery and the patient's age and condition.
  • Generally, the survival rates for bypass and open-heart surgeries are promising, especially in hospitals with modern infrastructure and the latest technologies. The chances of a successful outcome improve with the patient's age, health, and the medical team's expertise. Proper post-surgery care ensures the best long-term results for both procedures.

Conclusion

So, whether it's a bypass surgery or a more intricate open-heart procedure, the reality is that heart surgery success rates are impressively high. While there's always an element of risk with any surgery, the key takeaway is that medical technology and surgical techniques have come a long way, and the future looks brighter than ever. So, if you or a loved one ever face the need for heart surgery, rest assured—you're in good hands, with a healthy chance of living a long, happy life!

Author

Doctor of Pharmacy

Dr. Deepanshu Siwach is a skilled clinical pharmacist with a Doctor of Pharmacy degree. He has 4+ years of experience and has worked with thousands of patients. He has been associated with some of the top hospitals, such as Artemis Gurgaon.

Reviewer

Senior Consultant 
Pediatric Cardiologist

Artemis Hospital, Gurgaon

Dr. Aseem Ranjan Srivastava is an experienced Pediatric Cardiothoracic Surgeon specializing in Minimal Access and Robotic Cardiac Surgery. He strongly recommends prompt corrective repair when possible....

Frequently Asked Questions

No, open-heart surgery is a broad term that includes various procedures done on the heart, such as valve repairs, heart transplants, and bypass surgeries. Bypass surgery (CABG) is a specific type of open-heart surgery focusing on improving blood flow to the heart by bypassing blocked coronary arteries.

Bypass surgery is a major surgery, but it's generally considered safe and effective. Like any surgery, it carries risks, including infection, bleeding, or heart complications, but the success rates are high. With modern medical advancements, bypass surgery has a 90% survival rate at five years post-surgery.

Both surgeries are complex and can cause significant pain, especially in the initial recovery phase. However, since bypass surgery is a subset of open-heart surgery, the level of pain and recovery time are fairly similar. Pain is managed with medications; most patients report feeling better after a few weeks of rest.

Yes, minimally invasive bypass surgery is an option for some patients. This method involves smaller incisions, and the surgeon may not need to open the chest fully.

Both types of surgeries have their own risks. Bypass surgery specifically has a 2-3% risk of mortality within 30 days after the procedure. Open-heart surgery risks depend on the type of procedure being performed, but they are similar to bypass surgery in terms of complications and recovery times.

Yes, most people who undergo bypass surgery can lead a normal life. Recovery involves lifestyle changes, such as adopting a heart-healthy diet, exercising regularly, and managing stress. Many people return to work, engage in physical activities, and live fulfilling lives. Regular follow-ups with your doctor are key to ensuring long-term heart health.

Looking for the best doctor ?

Fill up the form and get assured assitance within 24 hrs!

Reviews

Trusted by Patients